10 Red Flags When Buying a Used Car

By Martin Williams
10 Red Flags When Buying a Used Car
In this article

Watch out for these 10 warning signs when shopping for a used car—and learn how a VIN check can reveal odometer fraud and hidden issues.

10 Red Flags When Buying a Used Car

A used car can save you money, but it can also hide serious problems. Spotting red flags before you buy helps you avoid costly repairs and unreliable vehicles. Here are 10 warning signs every buyer should look out for.

1. Missing or Incomplete Paperwork

If the seller can’t provide the title, registration, or service records, it may signal hidden problems or even ownership issues.

2. Salvage or Rebuilt Title

Cars with salvage or rebuilt titles were often in serious accidents or floods. They may be unsafe or have ongoing problems.

3. Inconsistent VIN Numbers

Always check that the VIN on the dashboard matches the VIN on paperwork. Mismatched numbers could indicate tampering.

4. Signs of Flood Damage

Musty odors, water stains, or rust in odd places may point to flood damage—an expensive problem often hidden by sellers.

5. Odometer Issues

If the mileage seems too low for the vehicle’s age, or the odometer looks tampered with, walk away—it may be fraud.

You can verify odometer readings and mileage history by running a VIN check with our vehicle search tool:

Explore VIN Clarity
Example VIN: JA4MT21H33J043460

6. Uneven Paint or Body Panels

Different paint shades, panel gaps, or overspray often indicate past accident repairs that may not have been done properly.

7. Strange Noises or Smoke

Unusual engine noises, rattles, or smoke from the exhaust can signal major mechanical issues waiting to surface.

8. Warning Lights That Stay On

Dashboard lights for check engine, ABS, or airbags should not stay lit. If they do, repairs could be costly.

9. Seller Pushes for a Quick Sale

High-pressure tactics or reluctance to let you inspect the car are red flags. A trustworthy seller won’t rush you.

10. No Pre-Purchase Inspection Allowed

If the seller refuses to let a mechanic check the car, it likely means they’re hiding serious issues.

Final Thoughts

When buying a used car, trust your instincts and look out for these red flags. Always verify the VIN with a vehicle history report and get an independent inspection before you commit. A little caution now can save you from a very expensive mistake later.